Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Infection and Immunity, November 2007, p. 5079-5084, Vol. 75, No. 11
0019-9567/07/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/IAI.00525-07
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
| MINIREVIEW |

Department of Microbiology-Immunology, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois
|
|
|---|
-hemolysin of Escherichia coli and Bordetella pertussis adenylate cyclase toxin (ACT) and also secreted enzymes such as metalloproteases and lipases, S-layer proteins, a nodulation signaling factor, and the Fe-regulated FrpC "clip-and-link" toxin of Neisseria meningitidis (24, 27). In 1999, a new toxin from Vibrio cholerae was discovered that was initially categorized in the RTX toxin family and simply named "the RTX toxin" or VcRtxA (22). This toxin is produced by nearly all clinical and environmental isolates of V. cholerae, including the El Tor O1 strains responsible for the current cholera pandemic plus a broad selection of O139 and non-O1/non-O139 strains (7, 9, 10, 13). The toxin has been associated with increased epithelial cell damage in a mouse lung infection model (14) and has also been associated with increased virulence in a mouse gut infection model, although its role in intestinal disease is currently unclear (26). Recently, a related toxin from Vibrio vulnificus has been described and found to be important for virulence in mouse models (21, 23).
On-going study of the mechanism of action of the V. cholerae toxin in vitro has revealed that it is a totally novel type of toxin with many features that distinguish it from other RTX toxins. In addition, release of genomic sequences from human, marine, and insect pathogens has indicated that the toxins from V. cholerae and V. vulnificus are not unique but rather are the first characterized members of a new family of the RTX exoproteins. Within this new family, the structural properties of the toxins are highly conserved, but the catalytic activities carried are predicted to vary since the toxins are assembled as mosaics of 10 activity domains assorted among the various toxins.
In this review, the structure and function of the V. cholerae toxin are discussed in detail, revealing that this is a novel toxin distinct from the other RTX toxins. The structural features that define the new family and the mosaic structure of the activity domains are also discussed. Overall, it is shown that the V. cholerae toxin is a multifunctional autoprocessing RTX toxin, renamed MARTXVc, that represents a larger group of MARTX toxins produced by at least eight gram-negative species.
Sequences of novel A, B, and C repeats. The MARTXVc toxin is distinguished from other RTX toxins both by its size and by its novel repeat structure. Compared to the other RTX toxins, MARTXVc is much larger, containing 4,545 amino acids (aa) and having a predicted molecular mass of more than 485 kDa (22). The related toxin from V. vulnificus (MARTXVv) is also extremely large, containing 5,206 aa and having a predicted molecular mass of 556 kDa, and it is now recognized as the largest single polypeptide toxin, surpassing MARTXVc (21). The large size of these proteins is due in part to the fact that about 25% of the primary sequences is composed of glycine-rich repeats, but it is notable that these repeats are distinct from the nonapeptide repeats of other RTX toxins. These repeats fall into three classes that differ in overall sequence but share a common G-7X-GXXN central motif. The first class, the "A repeats," were not identified in the original annotation of MARTXVc (22) and thus are shown in Fig. 1. These are 20-residue repeats with the consensus sequence GXXG(N/D) (L/I)(T/S)FXGAG(A/G)XNX(L/I)X(RH), featuring the central motif (underlined). There are 16 copies of this repeat in two groups at the extreme N terminus between residues 73 and 700 (Fig. 2).
![]() View larger version (55K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. A and C repeats of MARTXVc. Repeats were aligned using MacVector 7.0 (Oxford Molecular Group). Residues that align with the consensus are dark gray, while conserved residues are light gray. The consensus sequence is shown below the repeats, where x is any amino acid. The 9-aa RTX repeat is in the consensus sequence of the C repeat as indicated. Residues that form the core motif G-7X-GXXN are underlined in the consensus sequence.
|
![]() View larger version (25K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Representative MARTXVc toxin is similar to MARTXVv and 10 other putative MARTX toxins. The red regions are highly conserved among the nine MARTX toxins shown; this includes but is not limited to the repeat regions (indicated by vertical lines) labeled at the top as A1, A2, B repeats, and C repeats as described in the text. The central activity domains for each toxin are color coded as indicated at the bottom, where abbreviations for genes with known or proposed functions as defined in text and domains with unknown functions (DUF) are also indicated. Genes were identified using PSI-BLAST (1), followed by analysis of independent protein sequences downloaded from the National Center for Biotechnology Information database, with the following accession numbers: V. cholerae N16961 (Vc), AAD21057.1 (16b); V. cholerae RC385 (VR), NP_937086.1; V. vulnificus YJ016 (Vv), NP_937086.1 (6a); V. splendidus 12B01 (Vs), ZP_00989505; A. hydrophila subsp. hydrophila ATCC 7966 (Ah), YP_855898 (29a); Y. enterocolitica type 0:3 (Ye), CAJ90394; and P. luminescens subsp. laumondii TT (Pl1 and Pl2-4), NP_928648, NP_928647, NP_930444, and NP_930545 (12). The sequences of Xenorhabdus bovienii (Xb) and Xenorhabdus nematophila ATCC 19061 (Xn) were downloaded from www.xenorhabdus.org (16a), and a comparative analysis was performed using BLAST2 (33a). Diagrams were drawn to scale using MacVector 7.0 (Oxford Molecular Group).
|
The third class is the RTX repeats present at the C terminus of the protein originally identifying MARTXVc with the RTX family. However, while MARTXVc does have recognizable repeats, they are separated by 9 aa and have the central core G-7X-GXXN motif, making them an 18-aa repeat with similarities to both the nonapeptide RTX repeat and the A and B repeats. In the original report, 11 repeats were identified (22). After adjustment of the consensus sequence to align the core motif, 15 copies of this C-terminal repeat, designated the "C repeat" to differentiate it from the 9-aa RTX repeat, were identified; these copies included 2 copies that were independent copies, whereas the other 13 copies occur in succession (Fig. 1 and 2). Thus, MARTXVc is clearly distinct from other RTX toxins as it is comprised of glycine-rich repeats that are not present in any of the other RTX exoproteins.
Repeat structure is conserved in 12 MARTX toxins. Utilizing the A, B, and C repeat sequences of MARTXVc as the query sequence in a PSI-BLAST GenBank database search (1), MARTXVv and 10 other putative toxins that share the repeat structure of MARTXVc were identified (Fig. 2). The deduced protein products of the genes are all predicted to be large, ranging from 3,212 to 5,206 aa long. Alignment of the deduced sequences of all 12 MARTX members reveals regions of strong sequence conservation throughout the N terminus with 45 to 95% sequence identity and 62 to 97% sequence similarity. All but two toxins have the same number of A and B repeats. The exceptions are the putative toxin from Aeromonas hydrophila (MARTXAh), which is missing one A2 repeat due to an exact 18-aa gap in the alignment, and Yersinia enterocolitica MARTXYe, in which the N-terminal arm is shorter due to the loss of six A1 repeats. The region of alignment extends another 600 aa beyond the repeats and includes a putative coiled-coil region of unknown function. The C-terminal repeats are likewise highly conserved (62 to 99% sequence identity), and all members have 15 copies.
Analysis of complete genomes (when available) showed that most bacterial species identified have a single MARTX toxin; the only exception is Photorhabdus luminescens, which has four intact MARTX toxin genes that could produce four toxins (MARTXPl1 to MARTXPl4), three of which are nearly identical (12). Many of the identified bacterial species also have open reading frames that could encode other large RTX exoproteins, but the putative toxins do not have the same novel A, B, and C repeat structure and thus likely represent other new families of RTX toxins. Overall, the presence of the highly conserved A, B, and C repeats defines this new MARTX family of toxins.
|
View larger version (6K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Generalized organization of rtx gene clusters, except for Y. enterocolitica and P. luminescens as noted in the text. The operon structure as drawn is modified from reference 5, with the gene designations for the left-oriented rtxHCA operon based on the annotation of Y. enterocolitica rtx genes (NCBI, accession number CAJ90394) and the gene designations for the right-oriented rtxBDE operon previously proposed for V. cholerae and V. vulnificus rtx genes (modified from reference 5; 21).
|
Posttranslational modification by acylation?
Another property shared by the RTX pore-forming toxins but not by all RTX exoproteins is posttranslational modification by the addition of acyl groups to lysines (24). For both E. coli
-hemolysin and B. pertussis ACT, acylation has been shown to be essential for toxin activity against target eukaryotic cells (2, 33). The V. cholerae gene rtxC encodes a protein similar to the acyltransferase required for maturation of E. coli
-hemolysin and is located in the same operon as the rtxA toxin gene (5, 22). In V. cholerae, creation of an rtxC mutant that is nonpolar on the downstream rtxA gene has proven to be technically challenging, suggesting that production of nonacylated MARTXVc is somehow detrimental to bacterial viability (B. K. Boardman and K. J. F. Satchell, unpublished observations). Recently, successful disruption of V. vulnificus rtxC was reported and found to have no effect on virulence despite the fact that disruption of rtxA decreases the 50% lethal dose of V. vulnificus by 2 to 5 log units (18, 21, 23). This result strongly suggests that acylation is not required for MARTXVv toxicity and thus may not be essential for all MARTX toxins.
Instead, MARTXVc causes rounding of nonpolarized cells and loss of the integrity of paracellular tight junctions of polarized cells, yet the cells remain viable (15, 16, 22). Many toxins that cause cell rounding without directly affecting cell viability target the actin cytoskeleton. Consistent with this, 2 h after exposure to V. cholerae, cells in culture cease to bind phalloidin, indicating that no actin stress fibers remain (16). Thus, this toxin is associated with depolymerization of actin and loss of cell structure, not pore formation. This loss of cell structure is due to two distinct activities of MARTXVc.
Actin cross-linking. A Western blot of lysates from cells infected with V. cholerae revealed that actin itself is one target of toxin action. Coincident with the disassembly of actin, the actin monomers become covalently linked into multimers, a phenotype called actin laddering (16). The domain essential for this activity has been located between aa 1963 and 2419. Deletion of this region, called the "actin cross-linking domain (ACD)," from MARTXVc eliminated laddering, demonstrating that this region is essential. Furthermore, cross-linking of actin occurred in cells transiently expressing the domain separated from the remainder of the toxin, a result showing that this domain is sufficient for the actin laddering phenotype (31). Finally, purified ACD has been demonstrated to cross-link actin in vitro in the absence of other cellular proteins, demonstrating that the ACD is an enzyme that directly binds actin and introduces the covalent cross-link (8).
Rho GTPase inactivation. Since the ACD is essential for actin cross-linking, it was expected that deletion of the ACD would also inactivate cell rounding. However, elimination of the ACD did not ablate cell rounding, revealing that this large toxin has a second cell-rounding activity (31). Further investigation has shown that this second activity is mediated through inactivation of the small Rho GTPases Rho, Rac, and CDC42 (32). This activity has been mapped to a specific domain of the toxin located at aa 2552 to 3099, termed the "Rho GTPase inactivation domain (RID)." When transiently expressed in cells, the RID caused cell rounding, and purified RID induced both cell rounding and Rho inactivation when it was delivered directly to the cytosol of cells (32). The mechanism of Rho GTPase inactivation has not yet been determined, but current data suggest that the RID targets the Rho GTPase signaling pathways rather than the small GTPases directly by a mechanism that is not shared with other known Rho-inactivating toxins (32). Hence, MARTXVc is a multifunctional toxin that causes disassembly of the cell cytoskeleton by both direct and indirect mechanisms.
The CPD located upstream of the C repeats is conserved in all of the MARTX toxins (Fig. 2), indicating that autoprocessing is a defining feature of this family of toxins. Detailed alignments show that all MARTX toxin CPDs include the histidine and cysteine that comprise the catalytic dyad, indicating that all of them could be enzymatically functional (30). Thus, it seems that all MARTX toxins have the propensity for autocatalytic cleavage.
Overall, the toxins appear to have a mosaic structure in the central region, in which 10 different domains are assorted among the individual toxins (Fig. 2). For example, the ACD is shared by the MARTXVc and MARTXAh toxins but is absent from other toxins. By contrast, the RID is found in MARTXVc, MARTXVv, and both toxins from Xenorhabdus spp. MARTXVc clearly has an additional domain shared with five other toxins that has yet to be characterized. A conserved domain search revealed that this uncharacterized domain is a member of the alpha-beta (
/ß) hydrolase protein family (25). These proteins share a common stable tertiary structure for presentation of a catalytic triad, although the enzymatic activities vary and the enzymes include proteases, elastases, lipases, and esterases (17).
Even though MARTXVc toxins encoded in nine sequenced V. cholerae genomes are nearly identical, the putative MARTX toxin from the environmental isolate RC385 (MARTXVR) is entirely distinct. As sequenced, the toxin gene has a frameshift mutation, but there may be other isolates in which the gene is intact. The putative full-length toxin could have three toxic activities: two domains having unknown functions (DUF1 and DUF2) shared with MARTXYe and another domain that is conserved with the adenylate cyclase domain from Pseudomonas aeruginosa type III secretion effector ExoY, indicating that this toxin is likely an adenylate cyclase toxin.
The large size of MARTXVv is due to its five putative activity domains. In addition to RID and the
/ß hydrolase, this toxin has a domain with an unknown function (DUF3) shared with the Xenorhabus sp. toxins. The fourth domain is shared with four other MARTX toxins and is also similar to a domain of the P. luminescens Mcf toxins (makes caterpillars floppy). Mcf1 has been shown to induce apoptosis of mammalian cells, although the domain of the toxin that induces apoptosis has not been mapped to a specific region (11, 35). The fifth domain of MARTXVv is shared with three other MARTX toxins and is also similar to a portion of the Pasteurella mitogenic toxin (PMT). The structure of the C terminus of PMT has recently been solved and shown to fold into three domains (19). The region conserved in the MARTX toxins corresponds to C1, a lipid membrane localization domain, plus C2, a domain with two
/ß hydrolase fold subdomains, suggesting that this domain could have two catalytic activities (19). Although the mitogenic activity of PMT is localized to the C terminus (6, 28), a thiol protease found within C3 is proposed to be the catalytic region (19), Thus, potential activities carried by the C1 and C2 domains and thus MARTX toxins are currently unknown. However, even though the thiol protease of PMT is not related to the MARTX CPD, analogy to studies with MARTXVc CPD could suggest that the thiol protease is required for autoprocessing of PMT to release C1 and C2 to the cytosol, indicating that the mitogenic activity of PMT could be conserved in the MARTX toxins. Recently, mutations in the rtxA gene of V. vulnificus have been characterized, and it has been shown that MARTXVv is a cytolysin that causes lysis of epithelial cells within 90 to 180 min after addition of bacteria (21, 23). Thus, one of the five activity domains of MARTXVv could be an enzyme that perturbs membrane integrity, although the region of the toxin responsible for cell lysis has yet to be identified.
The last activity domain of the MARTX toxins is a domain with an unknown function (DUF4) carried by Vibrio splendidus MARTX and the four MARTXPl toxins. This domain is apparently the only activity domain of MARTXPl1, suggesting that this toxin may not be multifunctional. However, this domain is over 500 aa long and may itself have several activities that always recombine into new toxins as a single domain. Thus, it is possible that all the MARTX toxins are indeed multifunctional and that one or more activities are associated with each identified domain.
![]() View larger version (49K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Comprehensive model for delivery of MARTX toxin activity domains as detailed in the text.
|
Published ahead of print on 23 July 2007. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»